The President's Medal is the highest award presented to a graduating senior. The Student Affairs Committee of the Faculty Senate selects the recipient. The student is chosen on scholarship and service to the University. He or she receives a medal engraved with the University seal, the person's name, and the year the award was presented.
| 2023 | Savannah M. Staples '23 | English Teaching |
| 2022 | Anna M. Ardelean '22 | Political Science |
| 2021 | Meghan B. McCrary '21 | Biology |
| 2020 | Jean Marie Uwimana '20 | Economics and Mathematics |
| 2019 | Riley K. Cornett '19 | Communication Studies |
| 2018 | Virgilio E. Paulino | Political Science and Philosophy |
| 2017 | Evan K. Steiler | Biology |
| 2016 | Maria A. Anderson | Biology |
| 2015 | Shelby N. Tarantino | Exercise Science |
| 2014 | Jordan K. Morrison | Nursing |
| 2013 | Ashley R. Hilton | Social Work |
| 2012 | Phillip H. Behrens IV | Biology |
| 2011 | Steven L. Geiss | Biology |
| 2010 | Meral K. El Ramahi | Biology |
| 2009 | Jamie L. Johnson | Chemistry |
| 2008 | Samuel C. Bowles | English |
| 2007 | Award declined. | |
| 2006 | Lindsey A. McGowan | Elementary Education |
| 2005 | Samuel J. Tucker | Chemistry and Marketing |
| 2004 | Rachel Miller | Mathematics, Math Teaching and French |
| 2003 | Walter J. Jermakowicz | Biology, Chemistry and German |
| 2002 | Rick A. Hudson | Mathematics |
| 2001 | Eric J. Norton | English |
| 2000 | Jill Marie Welden | Accounting |
| 1999 | Mary Beth Cable | Communications |
| 1998 | Lisa Ann Amiano | Elementary Education |
| 1997 | Nicole L. Cable | Chemistry |
| 1996 | Lisabeth A. Luther | Political Science and Sociology |
| 1995 | Chad J. Hartman | Mathematics |
| 1994 | Travis J. Taylor | Biology |
| 1993 | Sherry M. Begle | Biology |
| 1992 | Debbie L. Seib | Accounting and Computer Information Systems |
| 1991 | Brad A. Schepers | Mechanical Engineering Technology |